Comics and Anime Club at UVa
The power of Haruhi compels you.

Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica


CAINE Textboards > Animation
[new topic] [reply] Goto page: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, Last Page, etc
View Previous Topic :: View Next Topic
Author Message
Peaches
Are they still on Namek?


Joined: Sep 2008
Power level: 427
Location: the Nomad
No. 25968 Posted: Feb 26 2011, 14:57:43 [quick quote] [quote]

this just made my day
_________________
haha I'm the 69th member

if you recognize my avatar, I need your help, BRING SUPER GLUE!

Back to Top [profile] [pm] [aim]
 
Akibastranger
DIABEETUS


Joined: Aug 2007
Power level: 3769
Location: Private Villa
No. 25970 Posted: Feb 27 2011, 02:56:51 [quick quote] [quote]

This was my face when Honya was right about EVERYTHING. -->

Also, I am very sad about this business with Sayaka. I think she was kind of my favorite character. In compensation, I demand doujins where aggressive Sayaka takes Kamijo-kun by force.

Back to Top [profile] [pm] [email] [mal] [aim]
 
Akibastranger
DIABEETUS


Joined: Aug 2007
Power level: 3769
Location: Private Villa
No. 26153 Posted: Mar 4 2011, 12:39:32 [quick quote] [quote]

So what does everyone think of the latest episode (9)? SPOILERS AHEAD LOL

It left a bit of a bad taste in my mouth, personally. I feel like Kyouko's 180-degree character shift happened too abruptly for me to take it seriously, and I didn't feel like Sayaka was a powerful-enough Witch to warrant Kyouko sacrificing herself to take her down. Sayaka was low-tier in terms of power level, so shouldn't she also be a low-tier Witch? Or did emotional attachments get the better of our heroines? Either way, it seems like they were trying a bit too hard to set up the Walpurgis finale in a particular fashion and threw out a perfectly good character in the process.

Maybe I'm just mad because Kyouko and Sayaka were tied as my favorite characters and now they're both dead.

Also, assuming he's not misdirecting, I am unhappy about Kyuubey being an alien. I liked it better when he was Mephistopheles.

Back to Top [profile] [pm] [email] [mal] [aim]
 
ChenChilla
Fluffy Magical Companion


Joined: Sep 2009
Power level: 249
Location: Virginia
No. 26154 Posted: Mar 4 2011, 22:17:50 [quick quote] [quote]

u should put *spoiler warning* on ur post ^

but, at least I can be content now with the sad/hopelessness, instead of being angry and confused at what was the anime is trying to get at.  So, the anime is awesome already, fingers crossed for a tear jerking ending
_________________

Back to Top [profile] [pm] [mal] [google] [aim]
 
eckstee
Azu-nyan ponder


Joined: May 2007
Power level: 2676
No. 26156 Posted: Mar 5 2011, 07:22:39 [quick quote] [quote]

Original post by ChenChilla
u should put *spoiler warning* on ur post ^

or use spoiler tags...
_________________

Twitter | Blag | MAGFest 13 - January 23-26, 2015 (Fri-Mon!), at the Gaylord (National Harbor, MD)!

Back to Top [profile] [pm] [www] [mal] [google] [aim]
 
Akibastranger
DIABEETUS


Joined: Aug 2007
Power level: 3769
Location: Private Villa
No. 26158 Posted: Mar 5 2011, 11:34:38 [quick quote] [quote]

I know how to use spoiler tags. I just kinda figured nobody would be reading this thread anymore unless they were still watching Madoka. Also, "what does everyone think about (episode)" followed by WALL OF TEXT generally implies spoilers. Critical reading skills, people.

Back to Top [profile] [pm] [email] [mal] [aim]
 
Nodarg
whatever


Joined: Sep 2009
Power level: 401
No. 26159 Posted: Mar 5 2011, 16:00:47 [quick quote] [quote]

Original post by miki_sei

Also, assuming he's not misdirecting, I am unhappy about Kyuubey being an alien. I liked it better when he was Mephistopheles.


I actually quite liked that speech he gave to Madoka.  I mean, his rational as an alien makes much more sense than his rational would be as a demon.  Plus, the fact that I somehow kinda like him after that speech is kinda disturbing to me... =P

_________________
Becoming less of a lurker...

Back to Top [profile] [pm] [www] [mal]
 
Nodarg
whatever


Joined: Sep 2009
Power level: 401
No. 26166 Posted: Mar 7 2011, 15:49:44 [quick quote] [quote]

HAHAHAHAHAHA
_________________
Becoming less of a lurker...

Back to Top [profile] [pm] [www] [mal]
 
Aorii
I post in alt.total-loser


Joined: Aug 2007
Power level: 1898
Location: Veni, Vidi, Nates Calce Concidi
No. 26173 Posted: Mar 9 2011, 13:57:12 [quick quote] [quote]

Original post by miki_sei
Maybe I'm just mad because Kyouko and Sayaka were tied as my favorite characters and now they're both dead.


Now you know how I felt about EP3!!! >.<
and Kyoko was my second... =\
TT_TT
_________________
"Allow me to warn you that challenging my ingenuity is a dangerous sort of project, and may tend to make your life a lot more surreal."
"You crazy bastard! I'm gonna treat you like shit until you reveal your true form!!!"

Back to Top [profile] [pm] [www] [mal] [google] [aim]
 
本屋
[EX Director Honya]


Joined: Aug 2007
Power level: 3641
Location: 妄想中
No. 26178 Posted: Mar 11 2011, 11:32:43 [quick quote] [quote]

>>26153
>>26173
I'm not following you guys...

But anyway episode 10...
Spoiler:
One of my favories so far. Confirms the alternate theory that me and Nodarg were discussing a couple of weeks ago. *high fives Nodarg*

_________________
Honya's MAL Card

Back to Top [profile] [pm] [www] [mal] [aim]
 
Akibastranger
DIABEETUS


Joined: Aug 2007
Power level: 3769
Location: Private Villa
No. 26192 Posted: Mar 11 2011, 19:13:43 [quick quote] [quote]

Dammit, I hate
Spoiler:
time loops.


What a great way to remove drama and tension from a storyline.

The plot details introduced in the most recent two episodes have Snape killed some of the appeal this series held for me. I'll finish it, but I'm not going to give it the same high score I originally figured it might earn.

Back to Top [profile] [pm] [email] [mal] [aim]
 
Aorii
I post in alt.total-loser


Joined: Aug 2007
Power level: 1898
Location: Veni, Vidi, Nates Calce Concidi
No. 26193 Posted: Mar 12 2011, 21:04:37 [quick quote] [quote]

Киоко сделал Октябрьской революции успеха





(think about it, this is so appropriate...)
_________________
"Allow me to warn you that challenging my ingenuity is a dangerous sort of project, and may tend to make your life a lot more surreal."
"You crazy bastard! I'm gonna treat you like shit until you reveal your true form!!!"

Back to Top [profile] [pm] [www] [mal] [google] [aim]
 
Peaches
Are they still on Namek?


Joined: Sep 2008
Power level: 427
Location: the Nomad
No. 26200 Posted: Mar 13 2011, 23:57:14 [quick quote] [quote]

one day...
_________________
haha I'm the 69th member

if you recognize my avatar, I need your help, BRING SUPER GLUE!

Back to Top [profile] [pm] [aim]
 
ChenChilla
Fluffy Magical Companion


Joined: Sep 2009
Power level: 249
Location: Virginia
No. 26205 Posted: Mar 14 2011, 10:17:44 [quick quote] [quote]

I will leave this here

http://3-me.net/flashdir/shootqb/

>>26193

how is kyubey communist, he is totally exploiting the masses >_<
_________________

Back to Top [profile] [pm] [mal] [google] [aim]
 
Nodarg
whatever


Joined: Sep 2009
Power level: 401
No. 26211 Posted: Mar 15 2011, 01:32:40 [quick quote] [quote]

I love Homura even more now...

Also, I really liked this last episode (I also didn't mind seeing things going as predicted).
*High fives Honya*
_________________
Becoming less of a lurker...

Back to Top [profile] [pm] [www] [mal]
 
You cannot reply because you are not logged in.
 
[new topic] [reply] CAINE Textboards > Animation GMT - 5 Hours is where it's at
Goto page: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, Last Page, etc

Powered by lulzbb © 2008 by Hark
Maintained by XT-8147
Although this organization has members who are University of Virginia students and may have University employees associated or engaged in its activities and affairs, the organization is not a part of or an agency of the University.  It is a separate and independent organization which is responsible for and manages its own activities and affairs.  The University does not direct, supervise or control the organization and is not responsible for the organization’s contracts, acts or omissions.